Critique for Camborne Redruth C S

15/09/2013

I would like to say thank you to the officers and committee for the opportunity to judge my first Best in Show appointment at this level. Thank you to all the exhibitors who gave me the pleasure of judging some very good dogs.

Best in Show & Reserve Best in Show
 

Best in Show – The Rottweiler, Verran’s Dromnagus All Eyes on Me ShCM. Wow, what a lovely young lady and my eyes were certainly on her. 4yrs old and still maturing. Super shape, and size showing strength with femininity. Lovely heady of good width, dark eye and correct ears. Well muscled neck to well laid shoulders laying over well sprung ribs of good depth. Strength throughout to a well angled rear. Correct topline, tailset and carrieage.  A true powerful mover.  She kept performing for her handler and could not be denied her BOB, Working Group 1, then she just kept on showing later in the day to win Best in Show.  Well done and good luck for the future

Reserve Best in Show - The Smooth Coated Chihuahua, Ayletts’ Angcherish Dusty Moon JW. Really pushed the Rottweiler hard. These 2 really stood out in this lineup. Well made and with such character. Correct head with good ears and bite.  A joy to watch on the move. And so pleased to hear she has been doing so well recently.

 

Best Puppy in Show & Reserve Best Puppy in Show
 

Best Puppy in Show – The Pug, Solomons’ Wendapen Benjamin Button. A youngster with a bright future. Full of type, lovely shape and well made.  Sassy on the move with lots of character. Still showing well here while others around were feeling the effects of a long day.

Reserve Best Puppy in Show – The Australian Shepherd Dog, Southcott’s Jotars Winning Design – 9mth Bl Mrl ASD. Very nice young lady of good shape and size. Very nice head. Good earset and carriage. Well made fore and aft. Lovely true mover and steady in profile. BP then carried on showing to win Pastoral Puppy Group 1 and then Reserve Best Puppy in Show.

 

AV Pastorial Veteran (4,2)
 

1st        Avery’s Lynviews Golden Toffee JW- Rough Collie. This 11yr old lady is in super condition for her age. Lovely shape, love her ears and expression.  Well made fore and aft and still carrying a good coat. Belies her age on the move. Best Pastoral Veteran.

 

2nd      Eldred’s Samajans Venus at Belthorne – Shetland Sheepdog

 

Best Veteran in Show & Reserve Best Veteran in Show
 

                                    

Best Veteran in Show – Pearn’s Brelade Miss Terious ShCM – Cocker Spaniel. This 9yr B still commands attention. Love her size & outline. Super head with dark eye. Well made and such a lovely typey mover. Has that cocker bustle and true fore and aft.

Reserve Best Veteran in Show - Avery’s Lynviews Golden Toffee JW- Rough Collie

 

 

Great Dane 
 Open Dog
(1,0a)

1st         Searle’s Jaydania Dean Martin. 4yr Fawn D. Upstanding young man. Good head and dark eye, nice close ears. Good angles front and rear, deep chest and level topline. Not happy on the move today. BOB

 

Boxer

Graduate (9,1a)

1st         Tonkin & Pellow’s Rosanyos Madre Mia. 10mth R/W B. What a lovely young lady who excels in many areas. Super shape and type with lovely head of good depth and breadth, dark eye giving a soft attentive expression, correct earset and carriage. Well made front assemble, good depth and spring of rib, short coupled leading to a correctly angulated rear. Good tailset and carriage. Well deserved BP and Puppy Group 1.  Shame that she looked a bit jaded at the end of the day in the challenge for BPIS.

2nd      Dawe & Bond’s Ewnybox The Cornsh Issue

3rd       Oldfield’s Rosanyos Myrtle of the Moor

Res       Rollason’s Ewnybox The Dark Knight

VHC      Cowell & Richards’ Astralune Volcanic Rock

 

Open Dog (4,1)

1st         Fielder’s Boxken No Issue for Ewnybox. 4yr Brindle. Good shape and masculine all through. Good head proportions, nice dark eye and good ears. Well made fore and aft with deep chest. Correct topline that is missing in many boxers these days. Well muscled rear. Typey true mover. 

2nd      Tonkin & Pellow’s  Rosanyos San Mateo.

3rd       Wynne-Eyton & Pellow’s Twrcyhru A Knockin Bett JW

 

Open Bitch (4,1)

1st         Tonkin & Pellow’s  Rosanyos Pocket Rocket JW. 2yr Brindle. Lovely head with dark eye giving correct expression. Well set ears. Well muscled neck with good arch, well laid shoulders. Strength and depth of body while remaining feminine. Good rear angles, again, well muscled. Clean true typey mover. BOB and then kept performing to win Working Group 4

 

2nd      Dawe’s Kai The Cornish Bear Another lovely B. Pushed the winner all the way.  A little longer and taller than 1 but with many nice attributes. Preferred her feet but preferred the crest of neck and overall shape of my winner. RBOB

3rd       Fielder Madam Cachet for Ewnybox  

 

Dobermann

 

Open Dog  (3,0a)

1st         Stanbury & Pilgrim’s Woodbriar Luciano JW ShCM. 3yd Liver D.  What a lovely young man. Powerful, masculine and compact.  Good length of head of correct shape, dark eye with correct earset and carriage. Well made fore and aft, deep chest and loin. Correct topline and set of tail. Tight feet. Very true powerful on the move with good reach and drive. BOB & Working Group 2

2nd      Pieters’ Supeta’s Will Eye Am Tuffenuff. Just 7mths and such a baby, but a nice one. Everything is there, he just needs it to come together. Pleasing head, well made with good topline and underline.  Very true and steady on the move for such a youngster. BP & Puppy Group 2


3rd       Edyveane’s  Kateamead Fernando

 

Open Bitch (3,2a)

1st         Stanbury & Pilgrim’s Woodbriar Fire Fly. 3yr Blk. Another nice compact powerful specimen. Pleasing B presenting a good outline, good head and eye. Well made with correct top and under lines.  Well muscled and moved well. Could be a little truer coming toward. RBOB

 

Alaskan Malamute


Open (1,0a)

 

1st         Oldfield’s Icewolf Stop And Stare. A very pleasing, well made young lady of good shape and size. Nice head with good breadth but retaining femininity. Dark eye giving an alert expression. Strong neck to well laid shoulders, deep chest to short strong loin & correct slope to the topline. Well muscled rear. Good mover. BOB

 
 

St Bernard

Open (2,1a)

1st         Spalding’s Amardapark Burton. 2yr D but still such a baby. Has plenty of promise but currently at the stage where everything is still growing.  Well made with a nice head, broad but still plenty of growing to do. Good bone and feet. Needs to learn to control his legs on the move.  Look forward to seeing him when he has matured. BOB


 

Newfoundland

 

Open (2,1a)

1st         Vincent’s Alpha Bear That’s Me at Cummgo ShCM. 4yr Blk D. What a lovely lad. Super head with dark eye and close ears. Well made fore and aft with good bone and feet. Super body with correct topline. Powerful rear quarters that he uses well ont eh move. A free easy stylish mover with good reach and drive enabling him to cover the ground. Can just imagine him using them to good effect in the water. Liked him a lot. BOB & Group 3

 

Siberian Husky

 

Open (5,1a)

1st         Raby’s Sun Beam. 3yr Red D. headed up an interesting class. Pleasing head, well laid shoulders and good shape if a little on the tall side. Would like more muscle behind. Moved well. BOB

 

2nd      Lees’ Lannvorekice Seven Star  9mth Puppy. Promising youngster, well made and good shape. Steady mover. BP & Puppy group 3

3rd       Lees’ Arcticskies Sea The Stars

 

Rottweiler

 

Open (5,1a)

 

1st         Verran’s Dromnagus All Eyes on Me ShCM.  See above. BOB, Working Group 1 then Best in Show.

2nd      Smith’s Auberon Fleur Delacour. Another lovely B who pushed the winner all the way. Well made with good head and eye.  Just preferred the feet of the winner on the day. RBOB

3rd       Smith’s Auberon Viktor Krum

Res       Stevens’ Majestic Spencer

 

AV Working


Puppy (3,0a)

.

 

1st         Oldfield’s Rosanyos Myrtle of the Moor 11mth Brindle B. Built on a light frame but with a pleasing head and nice eye. Well made fore and aft, correct brindle colouring. Steady mover with a good action behind and showing correct reach and drive.

2nd      Rollason’s Ewnybox The Dark Knight 

3rd       Fielder’s Ewnybox Major Issue

 

Working Group

 

 

Gp 1 - Verran’s Dromnagus All Eyes on Me ShCM - Rottweiler

 

Gp 2 - Stanbury & Pilgrim’s Woodbriar Luciano JW ShCM - Doberman

 

Gp 3 - Vincent’s Alpha Bear That’s Me at Cummgo ShCM - Newfoundland

 

Gp 4 - Fielder’s Boxken No Issue for Ewnybox - Boxer

 

Working Puppy Group

 

   

PGp 1 – Tonkin & Pellow’s Rosanyos Madre Mia - Boxer

 

Gp 2 - Pieters’ Supeta’s Will Eye Am Tuffenuff - Doberman

 

Gp 3 - Vincent’s Alpha Bear That’s Me at Cummgo ShCM - Newfoundland

 

 

Shetland Sheepdog

Graduate (9,0a)
What a lovely class. You always get good classes of typey Shelties in this part of the country.
 

1st         Marsh’s Mohnesee Black Again. 2yr Blk Tri D. Of good size and presenting a lovely shape with a good head and nice eyes, active, well set ears.  Well made under the coat and a true mover.

2nd      Eldred’s Dippersmore Starstruck at Belthorne

3rd       Moore’s Santiara Moon River      

Res       Prout’s Joles Silver Fox at Furzeland. 9 mth Bl mrl. Another of good body shape and pleasing head and ears. Perhaps would benefit from a little more length of neck but he is well made with a good coat. Nice mover. BP and Pastoral Puppy Group 2

VHC      Hirst’s Sundark Sunkissed

 

Open Dog (6,0a)
What a super class this was. Thank you.
 

1st        Hirst’s Sundark Starlight ShCM  5yrs mature Bl mrl, Lovely for size & shape, super head with correct earset and carriage. Well made all through down to his tidy feet. Coat not fully back yet but its whats underneath that counts. Super true mover, BOB & Pastoral Group 2.


2nd      Prout’s Penvean Golden Hind at Furzeland ShCM. Another super young man. Again with a good shape and pleasing head with good ears. Well made and moving well. So close to winning the class hence RBOB.

3rd       Moore’s Amethricken Ice Aqua at Santiara

Res       Marsh’s Mohnesee Mackeson

VHC      Eldred’s Belthorne Gifted And Black

 

Open Bitch (6,0a)
 

1st         Mitchell & Fiddock’s Evaldos By Starlight at Lowenek.  7yr Bl mrl. Best for shape in a varied class. Nice feminine head with good earset and use. Well made and carrying a good coat. Lovely mover.

2nd      Hirst’s Sundark Surprised JW

3rd       Eldred’s Belthorne Dark Enchantress

Res       Mitchell & Fiddock’s Belthorne Echo of Grace at Lowenek

VHC      Avery’s Landovers A Touch of Black for Lynviews

 

 

Samoyed

 

Graduate (2,1a)

1st         Page’s Taronikits Kalamity Jean. 8mths and beautiful. Super outline with a gorgeous head, correct bite, lovely dark eye and correct pigment throughout. Correct amount of bone and good feet. Well made with good spring of rib, short loin, and a lovely tailset & carriage. So true on the move. Handler needs to relax to get the most out of her and help her fulfil her bright future. BP, Pastoral Group 4 and Pastoral Puppy Group 3.

  
 

Open (2,1a)
 

1st         Prout’s Zamoyski Lucky Tamsin at Furzeland. 2yr B. Another of good shape with nice head, dark eye, correct pigment and good ears. Well made wirh good ribs and short loin. Good tailset and in good coat. True fore and aft but gave her handler a hard time on the move.

Bearded Collie

Open Dog (5,2a)
Three nice Beardies.

1st         Haskell’s Trystam Saint Geraint. 5yr Sable with correct outline and a lovely head. Correct eye and nose colouring. Well made with well laid shoulders, good ribbing through to a well angulated rear end.  Super free easy ground covering mover with correct tail carriage. BOB & Pastoral Group 1.

2nd      Haskell’s Trystam Larch

3rd       McCawley & Charlesworth’s Brimblebec Blue Blazer

Open Bitch (4,1a)
 

 

1st         Ransom’s Kirstancourt Keisha ShCM.  6yr Sable. Another nice Beardie with pleasing head and eye. Well made with correct angles fore and aft. Lovely free steady mover and carrying a good coat. Very close between the 2 in the challenge.

2nd      Haskell’s Trystam Saint Breaca

3rd       Carter’s Dychix Queen of Hearts. 8mth grey. Such a baby but a very nice one. Pleasing head, good shoulders and rear, developing along the right lines. Needs to be allowed to move out to achieve her full potential.  BP

3rd       Carter’s Dychix Queen of Hearts. 8mth grey. Such a baby but a very nice one. Pleasing head, good shoulders and rear, developing along the right lines. Needs to be allowed to move out to achieve her full potential.  BP

 

Rough Collie

 

Open Dog  (2,0a)
 

1st         Wilson’s Valleyhaven Crusader JW ShCM A 5yr old that oozes type. Lovely outline of good proportions, correct head that is masculine yet refined, dark eye and well set, very mobile ears. A Rough Collie that is built correctly and can move correctly. Pushed hard in the challenge by his sister but held on for BOB.

2nd         Avery’s Zannara Casanova (imp). An 8 mth very raw baby of good shape with a lovely head and lots of promise. Well made but a little uncoordinated on the move today. BP

2nd     

 

Open Bitch  (2,0a)
 

1st         Wilson’s Valleyhaven Coco Chanel JW ShCM. Litter sister to BOB. Smaller and feminine just as she should be. Super shape and gorgeous head with correct planes. Well laid shoulders and good rear. Anotehr good mover. Easy to see why these two siblings have done so well. RBOB

2nd      Avery’s I’m Posh an Smart via Vonarkle

 

 

GSD

An interesting class of 2 very different types.

 

Open (4,2a)

1st         Hackney’s Bilnetts Ace of Clubs.  6yr Dog. Good proportions and type. Very masculine and very alert. Lovely head, strong neck and well muscled body of good shape. Super angles with well laid shoulders, good depth of chest, strong loin, good bone and short strong rear pasterns.  So steady and powerful on the move. BOB


2nd      McLean’s Jadema Gemma at Carnmarth. RBOB

 

 

BSD (Tervueren)
 

Open (3,0a)
 

1st         Bond & McCartney’s Chatmar Highlander. Only 8 months but could not be denied for his esquisit breed type., So true to type, super outline and a gorgeous head with good mask and lovely ears. A little reserved to start but once he settled he move out beautifully.  BOB, BP and Pastoral Puppy Group 4

 

2nd      Simpson’s & Mackie’s Hawksflight Inc’s Quest ShCM

3rd       Jacobs’ Hawksflight Made you Wish

 

Polish Lowland Sheepdog

Open (3,1a)
Two very nice young ladies

1st         Sweet’s Chrevle Zophire.  2yr, very nice shape. Good head and dark eye and good pigment. Nice ears. Good overall shape and proportions but does have a tenancy to drop her topline on the stand. That said, she is a lovely mover, true for and aft and levels out her topline. BOB

2nd      Burdett-Coutts’ Chrevle Going for Gold.  A very promising youngster. Only 13mths  and coming on nicely. Good head, lovely shape and a nice coat. Rather unsettled on the move which spoilt her action.

 

A V Pastorial NSC

 

Open (5,2a)

 

1st         Omlo’s Autmans Kung Fu Ble – ACD 3yrs and what a lovely specimine.  You don’t see many and it is nice to find a good one. Very typey, super head, well made and solid to go over.  True powerful mover. BAVNSC Pastoral & Pastoral Group 3

2nd      King’s Ch Trelowen Heligan ShCM – Nor Buhund

3rd       Haddock’s Gilcoru D’Issy D’Brie - Briard

 

A V Pastorial Puppy (3,0a)

 

1st         Southcott’s Jotars Winning Design – 9mth Bl Mrl ASD. Very nice young lady of good shape and size. Very nice head. Good earset and carriage. Well made fore and aft. Lovely true mover and steady in profile. Carried on showing to win Pastoral Puppy Group 1 and then Reserve Best Puppy in Show.

2nd      Avery’s Njordr-Odinsonn Av Fjeldvidda (Imp NLD) – Norwegian Buhund.

3rd       Omlo’s Austmans Dock of the Bay - ACD

 

Pastorial Group

 

 

 

Gp 1 - Haskell’s Trystam Saint Geraint – Bearded Collie

 

 

Gp 2 - Hirst’s Sundark Starlight ShCM - Shetland Sheepdog

 

 

Gp 3 - Omlo’s Autmans Kung Fu Ble - Australian Cattle Dog

 

 

Gp 4 - Page’s Taronikits Kalamity Jean - Samoyed

 

Pastorial Puppy Group

 

 

   
 

PGp 1 - Southcott’s Jotars Winning Design – ASD

 

 

PGp 2 - Prout’s Joles Silver Fox at Furzeland - Shetland Sheepdog

 

 

PGp 3 - Page’s Taronikits Kalamity Jean - Samoyed

 

 

PGp 4 - Bond & McCartney’s Chatmar Highlander – Belgian Shepherd Terveuren

 

 

Gill Mugford Memorial Puppy Stakes (11,5)

1st         Prout’s Joles Silver Fox at Furzeland

2nd Roberts’ Lynwood Full of Grace at Polmennor Irish Setter

3rd Smith & McVittie’s Jaylynne Fabrizio Italian Spinone

Res Rollason’s Ewnybox The Dark Knight Boxer

VHC Allen’s Royaldach Rockin Robin Mini Smooth Dachshund

 

CRCS Open Stakes (16,8)

1st         Sullivan’s Flourenns Honey Star Dream ShCM

2nd Prout’s Penvean Golden Hind at Furzeland ShCM Shetland Sheepdog

3rd Prout’s Zamoyski Lucky Tamsin at Furzeland Samoyed

Res West’s Light of Paxton Spurs Boxer

VHC Allen’s Royaldachs Innocent Honour SHCM Mini Smooth Dachshund

 

 

 

Judge – Ray McDonald